The success of Nintendo is founded on a reputation of controlling each and every aspect of its offerings. From system manufacturing to game development, Nintendo orchestrates the whole process internally. Such complete dominance is uncommon in both tech and entertainment; perhaps only giants like Disney or Apple compare.
Yet, a single franchise exists as a significant deviation. Pokémon is possibly Nintendo's biggest property. Reports state that, by certain metrics, Pokémon earns more revenue than any other media brand worldwide. This wealth comes from ubiquitous products, game sales, and a booming card game business. But curiously, Pokémon is not wholly Nintendo's property.
Nintendo handles the publishing of the flagship Pokémon titles, yet the development work is performed by the separate company Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the entity behind the trading card game), Nintendo is a part-owner of The Pokémon Company. This entity oversees the global merchandising business that generates multibillions. Even, the massive hit Pokémon Go was created and published by third-party companies under a license from The Pokémon Company, operating at a significant remove from Nintendo's immediate supervision.
A History of External Success
For a business noted for its strict standards, this relationship seems inconsistent. Yet, Pokémon was not the first instance an external title fueled Nintendo's success.
The introduction of the Game Boy in 1989 presented Nintendo with a new piece of hardware. However, its internal teams had not yet found the ideal application for it. The solution came from elsewhere: Tetris. Nintendo's determined pursuit to obtain the rights for the Game Boy version of Tetris is legendary in the video game world. Tetris helped Nintendo to create and dominate the handheld console arena for years to come. This handheld division provided vital stability during challenging periods for its console operations and eventually led to the versatile Switch.
Despite masterful ports of its flagship franchises, a truly innovative handheld concept was not developed in-house. Instead, that spark came from former writer Satoshi Tajiri, founder of Game Freak. Upon discovering that Game Boys could be connected via a cable, he envisioned exchanging digital creatures, inspired by his youthful memories of collecting insects.
Game Freak pitched the concept to Nintendo, which quickly seized upon it. Yet, it took years for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the expansive RPG launched in 1996. Another few years passed before the titles, coupled with a card game and an animated series, burst into a global phenomenon. Pokémon prolonged the life of the Game Boy deep into its lengthy reign and essentially secured Nintendo's economic security.
Why Not Acquire Everything?
It may seem odd that Nintendo did not attempt to fully acquire Game Freak and Pokémon when its massive success became clear. A more aggressive company would have likely aimed a full buyout. Instead, the tripartite alliance between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was formalized as early as 1998. This developed into The Pokémon Company, which now handles the worldwide franchise.
Nintendo has a history of close, long-term relationships with chosen external studios, such as HAL Laboratory and Intelligent Systems, yet acquiring them. However, Pokémon's success was unprecedented. So why not grab the entire pie? Maybe the founding visionaries behind Pokémon declined to relinquish full ownership. It is also conceivable that Nintendo's executives, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the shrewd Satoru Iwata, took a conscious decision not to pursue complete ownership.
The Advantages of Distance
In hindsight, this partnership may have been remarkably wise. Would Nintendo have authorized the enormous array of licensed goods or dived into the trading card business with such fervor? The Pokémon Company, functioning with a degree of independence, could execute a voracious strategy to claim global attention and spending.
Nintendo benefited enormously from this windfall while having to get its hands dirty or risk its family-friendly image. When panic emerged about the trading card game influence, the focus was aimed elsewhere from Nintendo. Also, the sometimes mixed quality of recent Game Freak titles is a reputational cost mostly carried by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo directly.
A Lasting Symbiosis
Ultimately, this arrangement reflects a core Nintendo trait. The firm is renowned for not fixing what works.|Nintendo typically avoids needless